Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revisionBoth sides next revision
legal_identity_for_trees [2012-10-22 17:24] niklegal_identity_for_trees [2013-02-14 04:50] nik
Line 1: Line 1:
-===Workshop Notes===+===="Arboreal Identity" Workshop Notes===
 workshop on 20121012 and 20121013. participants; Heath Bunting, An Mertens, guillaume neu-rinaudo, reg carremans, karin ulmer, lucia penninckx, els de greef, rasa alksnyte, nik gaffney, maja kuzmanovic.  workshop on 20121012 and 20121013. participants; Heath Bunting, An Mertens, guillaume neu-rinaudo, reg carremans, karin ulmer, lucia penninckx, els de greef, rasa alksnyte, nik gaffney, maja kuzmanovic. 
  
Line 6: Line 7:
 Photos: http://www.flickr.com/photos/foam/sets/72157631828144552/ Photos: http://www.flickr.com/photos/foam/sets/72157631828144552/
  
-**Day 1**+====Day 1====
  
-Look at trees in Forest de Soignes / Verdronken Kinderen-Enfants Noyés+walk and tree identofication in Forest de Soignes / Verdronken Kinderen-Enfants Noyés
  
-**Different elements of identity** we looked at:+Different elements of identity we looked at:
   * origin   * origin
   * age   * age
Line 16: Line 17:
   * position/postcode   * position/postcode
  
-//- General parameters that create a 'normal' identity://+General parameters that create a 'normal' identity:
  
-//minimal//: name, date of birth, nationality ~ what's your name? where are you from? how old are you?+  * **minimal** for a natural person: name, date of birth, nationality 
 +  * if you cn provide an answer to the questions: ~ what's your name? where are you from? how old are you?
  
--> nationality is complex in general, and also for the tree+Nationality is complex in general, and also for the tree
  
--> can nationality be replaced by citizenship? Or by 'family'/species the tree belongs to?+in some cases nationality can be replaced by citizenship? Or by 'family'/species the tree belongs to?
  
   * //functional//: telephone, email, postal address, gender   * //functional//: telephone, email, postal address, gender
Line 30: Line 32:
  
  
--> create a 'corporation' around the tree? +proposal to create a 'corporation' around the tree? 
- +  A new legal persona is not necessarily a natural persona 
-A new legal persona is not necessarily a natural persona +  Personhood can refer to  
- +    * a human being (material essence, person living on the street) 
-Personhood can refer to  +    * a natural person (ID) 
- +    * an artificial person (corporation)
-  * a human being (material essence, person living on the street) +
-  * a natural person (ID) +
-  * an artificial person (corporation)+
  
 Personhood is defined by  Personhood is defined by 
- 
   * institutions   * institutions
   * a bureaucratical system    * a bureaucratical system 
Line 47: Line 45:
  
 'Natural and articifial persons' are considered to be the property of a human being, any property can be 'Natural and articifial persons' are considered to be the property of a human being, any property can be
- 
   * kept   * kept
   * passed on   * passed on
   * destroyed   * destroyed
  
--> we could wrap a corporation around the tree, insert some human dna-fragment in it...+we could wrap a corporation around the tree, insert some human dna-fragment in it...
  
--> if you don't have a birth certificate, you need a story+if you don't have a birth certificate, you need a story...
  
 **How do we proceed?** **How do we proceed?**
 +  + **proto-personhood** for trees: 'law', relationships of management & property
 +  + **philosophical**: why?
 +  + **physicality**: 'functionality', relationships to other people/things
  
-  - "proto-personhood" for trees: 'law', relationships of management & property +A lot of trees have numbers (is there a register? how is it managed?)we can presume all trees have a owner in Belgium but owners may have different status (forest, private property, city of brussels)
-  - "philosophical": why +
-  - "physicality": 'functionality', relationships to other people/things +
- +
-A lot of trees have numbers, all trees have a owner in Belgium but with different status (forest, private property, city of bssls)+
  
 So maybe interesting to add the parameter of 'owner/user' to the series of tree-parameters and talk about 'lineage/species' instead of nationality So maybe interesting to add the parameter of 'owner/user' to the series of tree-parameters and talk about 'lineage/species' instead of nationality
  
--> who owns it? Who has an interest in using it?+Q: who owns it? Who has an interest in using it?
  
 A tree is defined by lineage but also by 'the context': a tree in the city will be different, climbed, polluted, dependant on humans (candle stick prunage)...) A tree is defined by lineage but also by 'the context': a tree in the city will be different, climbed, polluted, dependant on humans (candle stick prunage)...)
  
--> where do the seeds come from? where did it grow up?+Q: where do the seeds come from? where did it grow up?
  
 We make a checklist and look at it from different perspectives We make a checklist and look at it from different perspectives
Line 77: Line 73:
  
  
-**Day 2**+====Day 2====
  
-looked at 'Oak du marais' in rue des Minimes, transplanted 6 years ago from somewhere else, serves as a 'bar', a meeting place, lighted by humans, hosts birds...+We looked at an 'Oak du marais' in rue des Minimes. it wastransplanted 6 years ago from somewhere else, serves as a 'bar', a meeting place, contains lights from humans, hosts birds...
  
-- look at trees in front of Walvisplanned to be chopped: platans, protest because they are the 2 only trees at that side of the Boulevard (between Yser & Porte de Ninove), and because they will be replaced by 3 new trees planted 3,5 m closer to the bar (effect: the terrace will be half as big)+Look at the plane trees (platane) in front of the Walvis. they are planned to be chopped downand a local protest was mounted because they are the 2 only trees at that side of the Boulevard (between Yser & Porte de Ninove). There is a plan to replace them with 3 new trees planted 3,5 m closer to the bar (effect: the terrace will be half as big)
  
--// discussion on the 'arboresceal persona'//+====discussion on the 'arboresceal persona'====
  
-We create it and integrate it in our daily language, start taking it into account -> method of 'invocation', it will start to exist +  * We can create it and integrate it in our daily language, start taking it into account -> method of 'invocation', it will start to exist 
- +  Look at the bigger picture: what if trees have legal identity & rights? How will we co-live with them: as separate entities or as chimera of tree/humans 
-Look at the bigger picture: what if trees have legal identity & rights?  +  a way to reconnect with trees, restore the natural-human relationship. e.in some parts of Lithuania it is unthinkeable to cut a tree. 
-How will we co-live with them: as separate entities or as chimera of tree/humans +  * can we create a map of Brussels' forest? 
- +  * do we see artificial arboreality as a business? what does it offer in terms of services (oxygen, fruit, fertile soil) - any shared good is value less in the dominant economic ideology of looking at the world -> maybe think differently? 
--> a way to reconnect with trees, restore the natural-human relationship +  look into the 'personalities' of the trees 
-f.ex. in Lithuania it is unthinkeable to cut a tree +  Nik reads Ecuador constitution that has integrated the rights for Nature in the law 
- +  we are the system: there is no authority imposing a system on us, we're the embodiment of a system, our 'identity' is a position of the system we occupy 
--> create a map of Brussels' forest? +  Heath's motivation: If we have rules to manage our identity, we can invent the rules to create identity 
- +  the human being can occupy most echological niches (of species that disappear)
--> see artificial arboreality as a business? what does it offer in terms of services (oxygen, fruit, fertile soil) - any shared good is value less in the dominant economic ideology of looking at the world -> maybe think differently? +
- +
--> look into the 'personalities' of the trees +
- +
-Nik reads Ecuador constitution that has integrated the rights for Nature in the law +
- +
--> we are the system: there is no authority imposing a system on us, we're the embodiment of a system, our 'identity' is a position of the system we occupy +
-Heath's motivation: If we have rules to manage our identity, we can invent the rules to create identity +
- +
-the human being can occupy most echological niches (of species that disappear)+
  
  
 Next phase: proof of concept, create prototypes Next phase: proof of concept, create prototypes
-  Look at information & data that exist already +  Look at information & data that exist already 
-  question the frequency & absence of parameters, reconceptualize location, speed, appearance of the aboresceal persona +  question the frequency & absence of parameters, reconceptualize location, speed, appearance of the aboresceal persona
- +
  
  
  • legal_identity_for_trees.txt
  • Last modified: 2014-03-14 14:27
  • by foam