Differences
This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.
| Both sides previous revision Previous revision Next revision | Previous revision Next revisionBoth sides next revision | ||
| marine_colab:transparency_experiment [2015-05-14 15:16] – nik | marine_colab:transparency_experiment [2015-05-14 16:11] – [Experiment design] 87.127.9.163 | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
| (an [[experiments|experiment]] from the [[workshop_201505|May workshop]]) | (an [[experiments|experiment]] from the [[workshop_201505|May workshop]]) | ||
| - | Experiment team: Andrew, Aniol, | + | Experiment team: Giles (FFF), Andrew (IEEP), Sandy (ClientEarth), |
| ====Hypothesis==== | ====Hypothesis==== | ||
| Line 32: | Line 32: | ||
| How would you design an experiment to test the Hypothesis? | How would you design an experiment to test the Hypothesis? | ||
| + | |||
| Experiment (in 2 months) is a scoping strategy that will focus on testing if it is feasible to: | Experiment (in 2 months) is a scoping strategy that will focus on testing if it is feasible to: | ||
| Line 45: | Line 46: | ||
| * On transparency | * On transparency | ||
| * On "value at risk" | * On "value at risk" | ||
| - | * Are there protocols that could apply to marine | + | * Are there protocols that could apply to marine |
| * How would we go about delivering this project? | * How would we go about delivering this project? | ||
| * Identify key industries | * Identify key industries | ||
| Line 51: | Line 52: | ||
| * Identify what extra information is needed? | * Identify what extra information is needed? | ||
| - | === Actions by July 2015 === | ||
| - | |||
| - | I - Scoping existing practices/ | ||
| - | * Has anyone else done anything like this before? | ||
| - | * Is there any ongoing action on this front? | ||
| - | II - Learning from similar approaches (Lead: Aniol / Sandy) | ||
| - | * What can we learn from similar initiatives (i.e. deforestation; | ||
| - | * What is the criteria used by funds/banks specialised on sustainable investment? | ||
| - | III – Shaping up the project (Lead: Giles / Andrew) | ||
| - | * Identify relevant industries. | ||
| - | * Identify comparable parameters / indicators | ||
| - | * What are the key environmental indicators we need to know for which sectors? | ||
| - | * What information is available and what information is needed? | ||
| - | * Select one industry to focus on to test this approach | ||
| - | |||
| - | By the end of the 2 months we hope to have enough information to decide if – and how – we take this initiative forward. | ||
| Line 72: | Line 57: | ||
| {{> | {{> | ||
| + | |||
| + | NOTE: In retrospective it seems that the pre-enactment did not fully capture to key elements of this proposal (above) such as the "value at risk" angle or the " | ||
| Stakeholder feedback: | Stakeholder feedback: | ||
| Line 93: | Line 80: | ||
| === Implementation === | === Implementation === | ||
| - | What is the experiment? | + | What is the experiment? |
| * Determine key environmental | * Determine key environmental | ||
| - | (How would you know if it has worked? //no clear answer//) | + | (How would you know if it has worked? |
| * Giles circulates FFF work on North sea limits work | * Giles circulates FFF work on North sea limits work | ||
| Line 106: | Line 93: | ||
| * will ask for ideas and initiatives that others the group know of before end of May | * will ask for ideas and initiatives that others the group know of before end of May | ||
| * Share initiatives between the participants to analyse; discuss early July or end of June | * Share initiatives between the participants to analyse; discuss early July or end of June | ||
| + | |||
| + | |||
| + | I - Scoping existing practices/ | ||
| + | * Has anyone else done anything like this before? | ||
| + | * Is there any ongoing action on this front? | ||
| + | II - Learning from similar approaches (Lead: Aniol / Sandy) | ||
| + | * What can we learn from similar initiatives (i.e. deforestation; | ||
| + | * What is the criteria used by funds/banks specialised on sustainable investment? | ||
| + | III – Shaping up the project (Lead: Giles / Andrew) | ||
| + | * Identify relevant industries. | ||
| + | * Identify comparable parameters / indicators | ||
| + | * What are the key environmental indicators we need to know for which sectors? | ||
| + | * What information is available and what information is needed? | ||
| + | * Select one industry to focus on to test this approach | ||
| + | |||
| + | By the end of the 2 months we hope to have enough information to decide if – and how – we take this initiative forward. | ||
| + | |||
| * Phone call on 3rd of June at 8.00 am to discuss progress to date and next steps. Note: time of call might change to 4.30pm (tbc). | * Phone call on 3rd of June at 8.00 am to discuss progress to date and next steps. Note: time of call might change to 4.30pm (tbc). | ||
| Line 113: | Line 117: | ||
| * information supply: | * information supply: | ||
| * knowledge about other initiatives? | * knowledge about other initiatives? | ||
| + | * information about the success/ | ||
| * publicly available information on how companies behave | * publicly available information on how companies behave | ||
| Line 129: | Line 134: | ||
| ====Progress==== | ====Progress==== | ||
| + | * 12 May 2015 - request for existing [[transparency initiatives]] | ||
| ====Results==== | ====Results==== | ||
nik